Reviews and Comments

Will Sargent

[email protected]

Joined 11 months, 1 week ago

I like books.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Review of 'Theories of International Politics and Zombies' on 'Storygraph'

No rating

This book started to concern me when it said that Marxism would be pro-zombie as it would view them as the proletariat -- which is ridiculous, zombies don't own the means of production, they're a plague on the workers.

It lost me completely when it started showed a picture of a woman in a miniskirt, holding a zombie head on a spike while talking on a cellphone and feeding fast food to a five year old, with the caption "Debates about whether women can “have it all” are likely to persist during the apocalypse." And keeps going with a chapter that talks shit about feminism. (See the quotes to the side for details.)

Fuck this book. Aborted.

reviewed Archivist Wasp by Nicole Kornher-Stace (Archivist Wasp Saga, #1)

Nicole Kornher-Stace: Archivist Wasp (Paperback, 2015, Small Beer Press) 2 stars

A postapocalyptic ghosthunter escapes her dire fate by joining the ghost of a supersoldier on …

Review of 'Archivist wasp' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

Suckered again buying a book at 2 am because all the reviews gave it 4 or 5 stars. Gah.

The protagonist isn't so much a character as she is a bundle of complaints. The idea of "ghosts" and the callback to a pre-apocalyptic world with a supersoldier is never really credible, particularly the science gadgets the ghost has, and the ending is ridiculous.

Cixin Liu: The Three-Body Problem (2016, Tor Books) 4 stars

Within the context of the Chinese Cultural Revolution, a military project sends messages to alien …

Review of 'The Three-Body Problem' on 'Storygraph'

3 stars

Entertaining, but mostly in the build up and in the present day -- for a while I thought it was going to be a Chinese version of M. John Harrison's Light, but instead it went into Greg Egan / Robert L. Forward territory with an unconvincing sidebar into a VR game.

Also, the premise is ridiculous. The trisolarans are as close as Alpha Centauri, but they don't see the solar system as an inherently safer place to be anyway? They have the technology to encode data into protons and launch an invasion fleet, but don't have the foresight to go to literally any other star that isn't exploding, nor use their incredible power over subatomic particles to correct their world? Why don't they send protons into their suns? Why don't they twig that the protons can work when in building it, they HAVE IT WRAP THEIR ENTIRE PLANET AND ABSORB …

Bible: NIV Zondervan Study Bible (Hardcover, 2015, Zondervan) 5 stars

A Christian Bible is a set of books divided into the Old and New Testament …

Review of 'NIV Zondervan Study Bible' on 'Storygraph'

5 stars

Empowered goes in for a board review and debrief of her activities in Volume 8. And has a really shit day, as her activities have made her a villain magnet, resulting in her having to take down multiple opponents or play them off against each other.

Empowered is one of those comic books that just shouldn't be as good as it is. There's a depth to it which makes it believable and fascinating even when not in the middle of a punch up, and while the characters are intentionally ridiculous, the situations (and how Emp gets out of them) are better thought out than 90% of the "straight" comic books you'd find.

Jo Walton: Among others (2011, Tor) 4 stars

Seeking refuge in fantasy novel worlds throughout a youth under the shadow of a dubiously …

Review of 'Among others' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

I like this book, but not because it's fantasy or science fiction. Because it isn't. It's a coming of age novel of a girl who likes science fiction, set in 1979 -- half if not two thirds of the novel is her talking about books she has read and loved, and they are all the same books that I read and loved as a child. I would have loved this books so much if I'd read it in the 1980s. It is pure SF nostalgia, with true respect for the past and the period, in the same way that Ready Player One is a paean to eighties computer games.

And it makes total sense that it got the Hugo and the Nebula. After all, who would love a book more about the love of Science Fiction?

At the same time... I wouldn't hand this to anyone who doesn't read SF. …

John Scalzi: The End of All Things (2015, Tor Books) 3 stars

Humans expanded into space... only to find a universe populated with multiple alien species bent …

Review of 'The End of All Things' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

I have to say that this is not a book, or even a series of vignettes. It's more like someone's idea of a creative writing workshop: every time the book hits a wall, change characters.

Scott Hawkins: The Library At Mount Char (2016) 5 stars

The Library at Mount Char is a contemporary fantasy/horror novel written by Scott Hawkins. It …

Review of 'The Library At Mount Char' on 'Storygraph'

5 stars

Fucking awesome.

In some ways, the best sign of a "magical fantasy" book is when you can't call it "young adult" and the characters aren't wish fulfillment fantasies. To the contrary, the protagonist, Carolyn, is utterly terrifying to everyone around her, even the non-human ones. Humanity is a choice, but humanity is also a habit, and Carolyn (and her brothers and sisters, the Pelepi) are out of the habit of thinking of themselves as human. And maybe they're not, any more.

Review of 'Cat daddy' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

I saw this guy on Animal Planet. I wondered how on Earth he got onto TV, or into cats. You don't find out why the TV show, but you do find out why cats -- Jackson Galaxy was an addict, and working at a shelter gave him something to live for.

It's hard to read Galaxy's discussion of drugs, and harder to read the withdrawal. But the hardest thing is reading the realization that he can't be the most important thing in the world and be able to listen to anyone else. In order to do his job, and pay attention to how a cat sees, he has to learn compassion, silence and humility. This kinda sucks for him.

Stephen King: Under the Dome (Hardcover, 2009, Scribner) 2 stars

Under the Dome is the story of the small town of Chester's Mill, Maine which …

Review of 'Under the Dome' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

This is Stephen King's idea of what would happen if you stuck the GWB presidency in a small town and the stuck a glass jar over the entire thing. This isn't subtle. It's the entire thing. You've got a knock off version of Dick Cheney (the Second Selectman) running the show, with his amiable but idiot First Selectman being the figurehead. You've got people saying there's a "heck of a job" being done. You've got no holds barred political rants about libruls.

Which is fine, if that's what you're into. But in 2015, everyone would prefer to forget GWB and Cheney ever existed, and the entire thing is cringeworthy at this point -- the payoff comes when people die because Dick Cheney is Evil and Stupid and they are Weak and Easy Led Sheeple. But it turns out that watching people die for being stupid or because they're disposible got …

Meghan Daum: The unspeakable : and other subjects of discussion (2014, Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux) 3 stars

Review of 'The unspeakable : and other subjects of discussion' on 'Storygraph'

3 stars

The first essay, about her mother, is fascinating. The rest of it... Do I really care that she wanted or didn't want kids, was in hospital, met Nora Ephron and Joni Mitchell, loves her dog, and doesn't like cooking? No. And amount of careful reflection is going to make me care. It would be interesting to see her look and talk about her husband directly, but she's very careful not to make him the focus of her gaze.

And oh my god, the... entitlement(?) with which she claims the title of "lesbian" despite not actually having any sexual attraction to women. Or calling transexual women "trannies" -- it's clear she has no idea how rude she's being, or how much like her mother (who is "intellectual" because she likes people who look smart) this behaviour is.