User Profile

Will Sargent

[email protected]

Joined 2 years ago

I like books.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Will Sargent's books

Stopped Reading

Brian Michael Bendis: Fortune and Glory (Paperback, Oni Press) 4 stars

Review of 'Fortune and Glory' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

A feel good, thrill a minute ride that will leave you breathless and wanting more!

Or an idea of what Hollywood is like, and how it tries to sort out good ideas from bad ones. It's funny.

The interesting thing is that Bendis is a damn good writer who has gone on to do some really amazing work since, and you could argue that Spiderman wouldn't have happened without Bendis's Ultimate Spiderman work. So in a way, he has made a big budget movie, and comic book movies are now "credible" in a way that they weren't at the time this was written.

Po Bronson: What Should I Do With My Life? The True Story Of People Who Answered The Ultimate Question (Hardcover, Thorndike Press) 2 stars

Review of 'What Should I Do With My Life? The True Story Of People Who Answered The Ultimate Question' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

Eeesh. It's rather embarrassing to even admit having read this. But I feel better, because at least I'm not in the position of having written this book. Having to read about Bronson's bald fantasies about being a writer and sleeping four hours a day so he could write more... I am in awe at the object lesson that Bronson provides. He has become a writer and fulfilled his dream, but only so he can write about himself. The people he writes about are backdrop, filler, to the quest that Bronson provides for himself. And it's also obvious that the people who Bronson writes about are those most like himself. All in all, a fairly nauseating experience.

reviewed Banner of souls by Liz Williams (Bantam Spectra science fiction)

Liz Williams: Banner of souls (2004, Bantam Books) 1 star

One of Mars's most elite warriors, Dreams-of-War, must travel to Earth. where she has been …

Review of 'Banner of souls' on 'Storygraph'

1 star

I had a hard time reading this book. It's one of the few science fiction books where I couldn't hold my suspension of disbelief.

Forget the haunt-tech bringing the spirits of the underworld back to life to serve in machinery. I'll buy that, I'll buy a time travelling 9 year old, I'll buy that all the males are dead and that people on Mars believe that they colonized Earth rather than vice versa.

But. This is a civilization which can jump from Pluto to Earth, and they don't have ubiquitous e-mail. Or cellphones. Or anything resembling a police force that would like to notice these interesting characters running around with guns. Not are there barely any characters surrounding the protagonists, there's barely a sense that the world reacts to their presence. It's a backdrop.

And looking at it more closely: what in this story had any science behind it, or …

John Brunner: Bedlam Planet (Paperback, Del Rey, Ballantine Books) 2 stars

A story about colonists on an alien world, and the psychological effects thereof.

Review of 'Bedlam Planet' on 'Storygraph'

2 stars

I don't know what it is, but the more John Brunner I read, the less I'm impressed. The writing is just so... 1950s. The characters are cardboard cutouts, the plot is derivative, and the payoff is contrived.

It's not awful. But it's not The Shockwave Rider or Stand on Zanzibar by a long shot.