Stephanie Jane reviewed Leaving Tangier by Tahar Ben Jelloun
Insightful, but awkwardly translated at times
4 stars
I wasn't initially sure I would enjoy reading Leaving Tangier because it took me quite a while to get into this novel. I'm not sure how close the translation is to the original French text, but at times sentences seemed clumsy. I also wasn't convinced by some of the dialogue, especially when different characters launch into speeches in remarkably similar voices! However, those points aside, Leaving Tangier gave me insights into the many reasons why North African people - mostly Morocccans here - feel compelled to abandon their homes and risk a treacherous sea crossing in order to reach Spain and, perhaps, a new life. I also learned about Spaniards making the reverse journey for exactly the same reasons decades earlier to escape poverty under Franco's regime. How come those stories of emigration aren't widely told these days?!
I appreciated meeting a reasonably large cast of characters which allowed me …
I wasn't initially sure I would enjoy reading Leaving Tangier because it took me quite a while to get into this novel. I'm not sure how close the translation is to the original French text, but at times sentences seemed clumsy. I also wasn't convinced by some of the dialogue, especially when different characters launch into speeches in remarkably similar voices! However, those points aside, Leaving Tangier gave me insights into the many reasons why North African people - mostly Morocccans here - feel compelled to abandon their homes and risk a treacherous sea crossing in order to reach Spain and, perhaps, a new life. I also learned about Spaniards making the reverse journey for exactly the same reasons decades earlier to escape poverty under Franco's regime. How come those stories of emigration aren't widely told these days?!
I appreciated meeting a reasonably large cast of characters which allowed me to understand a range of viewpoints, Moroccan and Spanish. Jalloun portrays desperation well, but also illustrates the fear and, surprisingly to me, the extreme boredom experienced by illegal immigrants who, having theoretically attained their goal, are unable to legally work or even perhaps to live with any semblance of dignity. Leaving Tangier movingly shows us people risking and giving up everything they have then, sadly for most of them, not being able to succeed. The novel does include violent sexual scenes and a strong theme is sex as currency. I was left feeling quite cynical at the way humans use and manipulate those they perceive as weaker than themselves.